Piña Napa Valley released their first commercial wine from the 1979 vintage. Piña in Spanish means “fruit of the pine”. Four brothers: Davie, Larry, Ranndy (look for his Bocce On column in the Yountville Sun) & John (John died in 2017) owned the winery until 2023 when the ownership was passed on to the next generation including Katherine Piña Capponi and her husband David with Larry continuing to serve an active role in the ownership and operations. The brothers are 6th generation Napa Valley residents and farmers. The only other Napa Valley winery run by four brothers that we know of is Buoncristiani Family Winery.
Both their maternal and paternal sides of the family have extensive history in California and the Napa Valley in particular. Their great-great grandfather Bluford Stice traveled with General George C. Fremont to California in a wagon train from St. Louis, Missouri in the mid 1850s. Bluford settled in Napa Valley in 1856. A tribute to his family name still lingers in Stice Lane located just south of St. Helena. Interestingly enough, Bluford’s son Lafayette owned vineyards in Napa Valley and was also a winemaker at what is now Martin Estate and at Inglenook Estate. And the Pina’s are related to the Wagner’s (Caymus Vineyards) through marriage.
All four brothers attended beautiful Cal Poly, San Luis Obispo. Course we are not biased at all considering CP-SLO was our alma mater!
Today they run a vineyard management company that their father John Piña and his wife Arline (Glos) founded in 1960. He called the company John Piña Jr. & Sons; today it is Piña Vineyard Management; the company oversees some 1,000 vineyard acres focusing on smaller properties, often in the 5–7-acre size. Their father also purchased the property in Rutherford perched on the lower slopes of the Vaca mountain range next to the Silverado Trail (the current site of their winery). Piña Vineyard Management has overseen vineyards for numerous well known Napa wineries including Pahlmeyer, O’Shaughnessy, Cafaro, Schlein, O’Brien Family Winery, Gemstone, Roy Estate & many others. The bottom line is this family has a very long history in the Napa Valley wine industry.
Despite being known for Cabernet Sauvignon, Pina produced their first wine from the 1979 vintage – a Chardonnay. The existing winery was completed in 1983 but their real push into making wine commercially did not begin until 2000. For a number of years this was primarily a custom crush winery; they rented out space to other winemakers including Keever Vineyards, Midsummer Cellars, Sawyer Cellars and Sjoeblom Winery.
A rusted tractor and other farm implements next to their sign makes this winery easy to find on the east side of Silverado Trail. A tasting here is a throwback if you will – to when tasting rooms were about the wine and none of the other distractions that one often finds these days. There is no fancy architecture, reflecting pools or brilliant artwork. The tasting room doubles as the cellar with wine barrels stacked up all around the portable tasting counter. From the outside, the winery has a “shed-like” appearance.
Despite its size, remarkably Piña Cellars has opted to remain a walk-in winery unlike a number of other Napa wineries who used to be open to the public by walk-in.
Piña produces some of the nicer Cabernet Sauvignons that we have tasted in Napa Valley. We’ve tasted a ton of wine for this project, and it is extremely rare when all the wines at a particular winery fit our palate like a glove such as here. The focus of their wines is on 100% varietal single vineyard designated Cabernet Sauvignon. Piña is not known for Chardonnay, but they do make a small, usually several hundred case production of an Oak Knoll grown Chardonnay from the Low Vineyard – a site next to the Muir-Hanna Vineyards which provided much of the fruit for Chateau Montelena’s award winning wine in the Paris Tasting of 1976.
Piña currently sources their Cabernet Sauvignon from 5 vineyard sites in Napa; D’Adamo Vineyard not far from the city of Napa, Wolff Vineyard in Yountville, Ames Vineyard in Oakville, Firehouse Red Vineyard in Rutherford and Buckeye Vineyard on Howell Mountain. The Piñas planted and manage all of their source vineyards – and own the Buckeye Vineyard and Firehouse Vineyard (the several acre steep hillside vineyards growing behind the winery). This particular vineyard is named in tribute to when several firetrucks were kept on the property in the small shed that one passes just before pulling up to their parking lot. Incidentally, Davie has long been a volunteer fireman – his help was greatly appreciated during the October 2018 fires that burned hillside acreage in both the Vaca and Mayacamas mountain ranges. And a big shoutout to the Piña Vineyard Management crews who were bulldozing in the western hills west above Pope Valley during several fires in late summer/fall 2020. Their efforts certainly helped save homes and potentially the historic Aetna Springs Resort.
Production is fairly small – usually only several cases are produced annually; some of their wines are produced in quantities of merely several hundred cases. When we first visited, they were selling out of wine far before their release dates so ‘futures’ of the wines were sold while they were still in barrel. As a result, during several of our early tastings we had to try wines from barrel.
Several important characteristics of Piña produced red wines are rich aromas and flavor, refined yet well-structured tannins and a depth of character across the palate. And these are wines that are not quick to market; they typically spend several years aging in barrel and then another several years in bottle before being released to consumer. As a result, their current release wines are often 4 to 5 years post vintage.
Select Wines
Chardonnay
The 2019 Piña Cellars Low Vineyard Napa Valley, Oak Knoll District Chardonnay is deep gold in color; the bouquet sports scents of melon, pear, golden apple, hay, honeycomb and deeper in the aromatics, a sweet tropical floral note including of jasmine and honeysuckle. The mouthfeel is supple and slightly creamy. This bottling offers flavors of peach, citrus, melon and light notes of warm butter. Lingers rich, with flavors of barrel influence including of toasted oak and cashew along with a variety of stone fruits. But its acidity is always there and keeps this wine lively and fresh across the palate. It drinks very well by itself. Very balanced.
Cabernet Sauvignon
The 2019 Piña Cellars Cahoots! Cabernet Sauvignon is blended with a nosh of Malbec and Petit Verdot. This wine is deep ruby and nearly opaque; the bouquet delivers plenty of fruit forward olfactory pleasure. And its not shy. These aromatics include ripe blackberry, boysenberry preserves, cherry pie (fortunately, Jayson Woodbridge does not have a trademark on using that term as a tasting note descriptor) and mulberry with additional notes of milk chocolate, mocha, cocoa powder and cinnamon stick. On the palate there are flavors of blackberry, dark cherry, Pakistani mulberry, dark chocolate and toasted cedar. The tannins are plush, plump and almost creamy in their textural feel. They linger with a gravelly character broadly felt across the palate accompanied by a light drying note which parrels the fruit in tandem before finally pulling away. This wine drinks easily and comfortably 5 years post vintage. It was aged in 50% new French oak barrels. In terms of character and complexity, this wine overdelivers for the price point. And according to Piña’s definition of cahoots, the word refers to a secret collaboration of wines.
The 2017 Piña Cellars Napa Valley Rutherford Cabernet Sauvignon Firehouse Vineyard is dark ruby in color; the aromatics are sweetly fruited, opulent and expressive including of blackberry, black currant, boysenberry and dark plum along with light notes of fresh peppercorn and a meaty nuance. Savory across the palate this bottling delivers bright acidity, along with flavors of dark plum, bramble, dried tobacco leaf notes and crushed black peppercorn. The tannins are earthy and dark, with a noticeable but short-lasting grip. Our first thoughts on pairing this wine were with a dry-rub tri-tip and a warm summer night – straight off of a BBQ.
The 2013 Piña Cellars Napa Valley Wolff Vineyard Yountville Cabernet Sauvignon is the softest of the wines we tried – shows notes of blackberry and boysenberry complemented by some wood spice characteristics on the bouquet along with earthy aromatics. For a robust vintage, this wine is quite approachable in its youth – there are layers of flavor along with fairly supple gravely type tannins anchoring a long finish.
In contrast is the 2013 Piña Napa Valley Firehouse Vineyard Rutherford Cabernet Sauvignon – shows lots of fruit on the bouquet – mostly darker fruit in its aromatic presentation – including blackberry, plum and dark cherry. Well layered, with big texture this is a wine that continues to show its power throughout a very long finish. Robust, course and gripping tannins linger for quite some time. The wine is also a bit savory with a dust quality on the palate along with decent acidity. After trying this wine, the first words that came to mind were “this is a Texas wine” ideal for those who prefer their Napa Cabs big and bold – preferably with a well marbled steak.
A couple highlights from older tastings include the 2005 Piña Napa Valley Buckeye Vineyard Howell Mountain Cabernet Sauvignon. This wine has wonderful earthy aromas, almost dusty. The palate is rich yet refined and is extremely well balanced with notes of blackberry and chocolate towards the long finish which is also slightly smoky with just a touch of toasted oak. The wines from their Oakville, Rutherford and Yountville vineyards are produced in quantities of typically no more than several hundred cases each vintage while the D’Adamo vineyard tends to be their highest production Cabernet Sauvignon.
They also make a vintage Cabernet Sauvignon based port-style wine (not every year) – as it says on the bottle this wine is meant to be “an after-dinner Cabernet. It is sweet but not overly so.
—
Steps lead up the hill a short way to their bocce court and picnic table at the edge of their vineyard; from here there are excellent views looking west over Napa Valley.
The Pina wines are fairly well distributed, and one can find a number of current release bottlings from online retailers. But they also sell direct; their wine club is appropriately called “Tilda” after the accent mark over the “n” in their name. For more information, to purchase wine and or to join their wine club, visit: www.pinanapavalley.com
Winery/Miscellaneous
Firehouse Vineyard
The Pina’s talk about their winery:
Great article you shared, Thanks for sharing 😉